CPS Drain & Plumbing vs On Call Plumbing, Heating & Air: which for repiping and pipe repair?
The differences that matter
- Track record with older homes. CPS has a specific, cited history of full repipe work on older homes, including a documented multi-year water line update project on a 1941 house, while On Call's praise centers more on diagnostics and first-visit fixes generally.
- Review volume and rating edge. CPS holds a perfect 5.0 from 400 reviews versus On Call's 4.9 from 251, giving CPS a larger sample size specifically validating its long-term reliability on bigger jobs.
- Depth of pipe-specific trust. One CPS customer describes the company as an ongoing advisor for water line work over years, a level of repeat trust that matters when a repipe project spans multiple phases or rooms.
- Service breadth beyond plumbing. On Call also handles HVAC and commercial and HOA work, which suits someone who wants one contractor for multiple systems, but that breadth isn't specific evidence for pipe replacement expertise.
Side by side
- Google rating
- CPS Drain & Plumbing: 5 (400 reviews)
- On Call Plumbing, Heating & Air: 4.9 (251 reviews)
- Services
- CPS Drain & Plumbing: emergency plumbing, drain sewer cleaning, water heater services, commercial plumbing
- On Call Plumbing, Heating & Air: emergency plumbing, repiping pipe repair, water heater services, commercial plumbing
- Best for older/vintage homes
- CPS Drain & Plumbing: Strong fit, with documented experience updating water lines in a 1940s house over multiple years
- On Call Plumbing, Heating & Air: Good general diagnostic skill, but no specific vintage-home repipe examples cited
- Best for multi-system needs (plumbing + HVAC)
- CPS Drain & Plumbing: Plumbing-focused only
- On Call Plumbing, Heating & Air: Better fit if you also want HVAC or commercial/HOA coverage from the same company
- Pricing transparency during repiping
- CPS Drain & Plumbing: Customers cite upfront discussion of costs and issues before work begins
- On Call Plumbing, Heating & Air: Customers cite multiple pricing options with no pressure to upsell
- Verification
- CPS Drain & Plumbing: Google-verified
- On Call Plumbing, Heating & Air: Google-verified
- Composite score
- CPS Drain & Plumbing: 94
- On Call Plumbing, Heating & Air: 93
Within 3 points of each other, so treat them as effectively tied on overall quality. The choice below is about fit, not the score.
What reviewers say
CPS Drain & Plumbing
For over thirty years, CPS has earned consistent five-star praise for speed and professionalism. Technicians like Robert, Gary, Joel, and Colleen diagnose problems quickly, arrive on schedule or early, and complete repairs the same day when possible.
Reviewers trust them with older homes and complex work. Staff communicate openly about costs and potential issues before starting. One customer called them "an advisor for all things plumbing" after years of successful water line updates to a 1941 home. Pricing was described as reasonable by multiple customers.
On Call Plumbing, Heating & Air
Nathan, JB, Tim, and other named technicians consistently earn praise for fixing plumbing and HVAC issues correctly on the first visit, often same-day or next-day. Customers value their willingness to explain problems clearly, offer multiple options without pushing unnecessary work, and respect time and property.
Dispatch staff book appointments quickly; techs arrive punctual and courteous. One long-term customer notes five years of reliable service across home, HOA, and commercial jobs. A church client commended a technician for expert diagnostics and attention to detail.
Which should you pick?
Pick CPS Drain & Plumbing if
- Your home is older and you want a contractor with a specific, cited history of repiping older housing stock
- You want the highest-volume, top-rated proof point (5.0 from 400 reviews) before committing to a big job
- You'd value an ongoing advisor relationship for phased pipe work rather than a one-and-done fix
Pick On Call Plumbing, Heating & Air if
- You want one company that also handles HVAC or commercial/HOA plumbing alongside the repipe
- You prioritize dispatch speed and multiple upfront pricing options before deciding on scope
- You're comfortable with a slightly smaller but still strong review base (4.9 from 251)
Verdict
For repiping and pipe repair specifically, CPS Drain & Plumbing is the stronger fit, mainly because its review record includes direct evidence of long-term pipe replacement work on an older home rather than general plumbing competence. On Call Plumbing, Heating & Air is a solid alternative, especially if you want a single contractor for HVAC and commercial needs too, but its praise leans more toward fast, correct diagnostics than toward the kind of sustained repiping track record that matters when you're replacing lines in a vintage house.
Still trying to decide between them?
Tell us your job once and get quotes from suitable plumber in Columbia.
Enquiries submitted through our contact forms may be passed to partner providers who perform the work, and we may receive a referral fee for those introductions. Our rankings and scores are determined solely by our published scoring method and are never influenced by referral fees.
FAQ
- Which company has more experience with older homes needing repiping?
- CPS Drain & Plumbing has a specific cited example of updating water lines in a 1941 home over several years, giving it a clearer edge for vintage housing stock.
- Does either business handle more than plumbing?
- On Call Plumbing, Heating & Air also covers HVAC and takes on commercial and HOA jobs, while CPS focuses specifically on plumbing and drains.
- Are both businesses rated highly for repiping work?
- Both carry strong composite scores (94.3 and 92.5) and high review volumes, so either is a credible option, but CPS's 5.0 rating across 400 reviews gives it a slight statistical edge.